Colleagues: Here are some of my thoughts on SSR's. If you choose to reply,
please either use the LISTSERVER address (fhbtalk_mg@listserv@msue.msu.edu),
or tell me if it's ok for me to forward it to the group.
If a silver bullet transgene was discovered next month (possible but not
probable), I believe the research system that had 250-500 well distributed
SSR's would have it in farmer's fields 2-4 years quicker than those that did
not. Asgrow tells me that they will cut a year off the backcross
development of a roundup ready soybean once Perry's SSR's are available.
Now, pretty clearly you don't fool around with DNA markers to track a
herbicide resistance. One spray of roundup and you've eliminated the
non-transgenics or non-expressers. In that case, its the reassembly of
recurrent parent genome that is accelerated by the SSRs. Our clan (cereal
breeders) still react rather violently to the suggestion of backcrossing.
Fair enough- call it 'donor genome elimination' rather than reassembly of
recurrent parent. ONE YEAR off development time in an annual like soybean-
that's got to translate to 1.5-2 or more years for winter wheat! My point
is not to suggest that SSR's be justified on the basis of transgenics. But
the difficulties of 'mapping' natural scab genes should not be fatal to the
argument that we need a set of high PIC value (in breeding crosses), easily
used, and well distributed markers in any event! Nor should mapping of
genes take precedence over development of the markers themselves. I argue
that the first thing we should fund in markers is a set of 500-1000 SSR's.
Putting them on the ITMI synthetic map will be a snap and may well be done
with other funding. I don't want to say that the tagging of scab resistance
alleles is not important. But we could put all of our money into gene
mapping efforts and not get the basic tool kit of markers we need for gene
deployment.
Therefore: Deployment time (years to release of a viable variety carrying
them) of ANY and ALL resistance genes (i.e., 1) transgenes, 2) unmarked and
phenotypically tracked plant genes, and 3) plant genes tagged with DNA
markers) will be reduced by one year or more if 500 good SSRs were
available. 'Good' means polymorphic in most breeding crosses, and well
distributed (10 or more per arm). That would save hundreds of millions of
dollars in scab losses in the time between gene discovery and gene
deployment by conventional means.
Conclusion: We MUST seek a set of SSR's in years 1 and 2 of this project.
Perry Cregan is ready to take this on. Costs could be as high as 2M total
for the 4-6 genomes we need to target (A,B,D, and H + maybe durum's A plus
durum's B)There may be unknown obstacles, but the evidence is strong that a
set could be developed in two years.
(We must also develop the NIL's and pops that will allow for tagging, we
must refine our ability to eliminate errors in measuring genotypic values,
and we must make efforts to find transgenes and new sources of natural plant
genes.)
I don't sense that this is a popular view at all. But I'm just hung-up on
this notion that we'll do an enormous disservice to ourselves and our
clientele if we do not push hard for the SSR set development now.
Please help dissuade me of these heresies! What's wrong with my logic?
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder
Michigan State University
wardri(a)pilot.msu.edu
(517)-355-2231(land)
(517)-285-9725 (cell)
(517)-353-3955 (fax)
address:
MSU/Dept of CSS
382 PSSB
East Lansing MI 48824
USA