Dear fellow scab workers, Here's my contribution to the discussion Rick asked for on conventional versus transgenic approaches to developing resistance to scab:
I am not convinced that the resistance that has already been found in T. aestivum is as woefully inadequate as some are suggesting. While it may not be as good as desired under highly favorable conditions, it has held up well in a number of trials. The trouble with throwing most of our effort into transgenic and molecular solutions to scab resistance is that we can't predict how long it will take to have cultivars in farmers' hands that will provide better protection than what can be achieved in the short term with proven sources of resistance. If the scab initiative succeeds it will be in large part because of support of individual farmers, grower organizations, millers, bakers, and brewers. I don't think these people are contemplating a long-term, basic research program as the best use of this money. They want some solutions as soon as possible. If we could promise that highly resistant, transgenic cultivars of hexaploid and durum wheats and barley would be in their hands within 2 or 3 years, then a huge investment in this aspect of the program would be justified, but I don't think that is the case. We can, however, tell them that hexaploid wheat cultivars with the Chinese or Frontana resistance will be released over the next few years, starting perhaps as early as this year. I think it is wiser to put bulk of the plant improvement resources into an approach that will pay off quickly. Once this has been accomplished, relatively more resources can be progressively diverted to longer term and riskier solutions to scab, that may have a greater pay off if they do work. Regards, Greg Shaner