Please see a message from R. Sears of Kansas State below. I know that this
may be a repeat for many of you- but to be certain that all people in the
scab community see the dialogue that's ongoing I've taken the liberty to
forward this through the scab LISTSERVER.
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder
Michigan State University
wardri(a)pilot.msu.edu
(517)-355-2231(land)
(517)-285-9725 (cell)
(517)-353-3955 (fax)
address:
MSU/Dept of CSS
382 PSSB
East Lansing MI 48824
USA
-----Original Message-----
From: Rollie Sears [mailto:rs@ksu.edu]
Sent: Thursday, March 05, 1998 9:14 PM
To: Rick ward; Andris Kleinhofs
Cc: Olin Anderson; FarmAndy1; Mike Davis; Dave Torgerson; Scott Haley;
Sam Hazen; Rollie Sears; Richard Frohberg; Rich Horsley; Pat Hayes; Mark
Sorrels; Lynne Dahleen; Kim Cambell; Judy St. John; Jackie Rudd; J
Jvorak; J Dubcovsky; Heidi Kaeppler; Fred Kolb; Elias Elias; Ed Souza;
Don Rassmason; Dave Van Sanford; Chuck Murphy; Calvin O. Qualset; Bob
Busch; Anne McKendry; Raj at CIMMYT; Jim Peterson
Subject: RE: 99 budget
colleagues;
I agree that the transformation section is to small. And I would agree
that
money should be taken out of the breeding section. Even though breeding
programs and associated quality efforts will be impacted the focus of this
funding should be directed towards identifying the highest level of
tolerance/resistance available in both barley and wheat. At this point
dollars
for associated other breeding goals should be minimized in the proposal.
Just a comment regarding the progress being made by "conventional" plant
breeders. In a very short period of time a number of sources of tolerance
have
been identified. Varieties with improved reaction to FHB have and are being
released. It is my understanding that tolerance levels have now exceeded
Sumai
3 in good agronomic backgrounds. In visiting with breeders working on the
problems they have been encouraged by the recent progress being made,
despite
the set backs from observing last years infection in the northern valley.
Screening systems have improved substantially. And the breeders are just
beginning to really explore the possible recombinants being generated from
sharing germplasm. I think remarkable progress has been made, especially by
the
spring wheat breeders, and the winter wheat breeders are on the right path
also.
I am not terribly swayed by the suggestion that the best way to solve this
problem is through transgenics. 5 years from today I would bet a steak
dinner
with anyone that resistance levels identified in conventional breeding
systems
will far exceed anything we come up with via transgenics.
Rick, I would support increasing both transgenic efforts and germplasm
efforts.
As you've pointed out in your initial outlines "no stone must be left
unturned"
. As we need to keep the budget within guidelines and accountable lets keep
the
focus on FHB and not try to build infrastructure within the various
programs.
Rollie Sears
>> >1. Food Safety and Post-Harvest Management Research Network
>$1,000,000
>> >(19%)
>> >
>> >2. Strengthening and Expansion of Ongoing Plant Breeding Efforts:
>> >Conventional and Molecular Approaches to Variety Development and
>Germplasm
>> >Enhancement $2,400,000 (46 %)
>> >
>> >3. Regional Advanced Breeding Material Evaluation Nursery System
>> >$100,000
>> >(2 %)
>> >
>> >4. Fungicide Application Technology Research Network $350,000
>(7 %)
>> >
>> >5. Germplasm Introduction and Evaluation System $250,000 (5 %)
>> >6. Epidemiology and Crop Management Research $800,000 (15 %)
>> >
>> >7. Project Coordination and Research Information Network $100,000
>> >(2 %)
>> >
>> >8. transformation/transgenics $200,000 (4 %)
>> >
>> >
>> >Annual Total $5,200,000 (100 %)
>> >
>> >
>> >Rick Ward
>> >
>> >Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder
>> >Michigan State University
>> >wardri(a)pilot.msu.edu
>> >(517)-355-2231(land)
>> >(517)-285-9725 (cell)
>> >(517)-353-3955 (fax)
>> >address:
>> >MSU/Dept of CSS
>> >382 PSSB
>> >East Lansing MI 48824
>> >USA
>> >
>> >Attachment converted: Macintosh HD:99bud1 w6.doc (WDBN/MSWD) (00002C2D)
>>
>> A. Kleinhofs
>> Dept. Crop and Soil Sciences
>> Washington State University
>> Pullman, WA 99164-6420
>> USA
>> Fax: 1-509-335-8674
>> Phone: 1-509-335-4389
>>
>>
>>
>