Following from Bob Busch:
GROUP:
IN MY ESTIMATION TRANSGENICS PROVIDE A NEW AND POSSIBLE 'SILVER BULLET' WHEN COMBINED WITH OTHER 'NATURAL' GENES FOR SCAB TOLERANCE. I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE BEYOND TOLERANCE. UNDER VERY HEAVY INFECTION, WE STILL GET CONSIDERABLE DAMAGE TO KERNELS OF COMBINED SOURCES OF RESISTANCE. ADDITION OF TRANSGENICS (AFPs), ALTHOUGH IN THE FUTURE, APPEAR TO BE ATLEAST AN EXPLORABLE METHOD OF INTRODUCING ADDITIONAL AND HIGHER LEVELS OF RESISTANCE. MAPPING OF SCAB GENES IS VERY DIFFICULT, SINCE IT DEPENDS UPON HIGHLY REPEATABLE MEASURE OF RESISTANCE, AND THIS IS POSSIBLE FOR TYPE 2 RESISTANCE ONLY. WE DO NOT HAVE A HANDLE OF TYPE 3 OR TYPE 1. I DO NOT ARGUE THE MERIT OF MAPPING, BUT HAVE CONSIDERABLE APPREHENSION IF WE SELL SCAB RESISTANCE BASED ON MAPPING. A COMPLETE MAP IN WHEAT IS DESIRABLE, BUT WE NEED TO KNOW THE CHROMOSOME LOCATIONS etc. OF THESE MARKERS, AND TO KNOW THE SATURATION THAT IT ALLOWS. FURTHER, EACH BREEDING PROGRAM THAT WILL UTILIZE THE MAPS WILL NEED THEIR OWN SERVICE LAB TO EVALUATE GERMPLASM, SINCE THE RESEARCH LABS CAN NOT AFFORD TO DO THIS. I BELIEVE THAT TRANSGENICS NEED SUPPORT CERTAINLY TO THE LEVEL OF MAPPING IF SCAB RESISTANCE IS THE MAIN GOAL. CERTAINLY, JIM ANDERSON HAS BEEN ATTEMPTING TO MAP FOR TYPE 2 RESISTANCE WITH GREAT DIFFICULTY FOR THE PAST 3 YEARS. I THINK BARLEY HAS ALMOST NO ALTERNATIVE EXCEPT TRANSGENES TO ALLOW ALMOST IMMUNITY TO SCAB OR TO DETOXIFY DON. THEIR MARKETING REQUIRMENTS ARE MORE STRINGENT THAN WHEAT. WE ALL KNOW THAT PLEOTROPHIC EFFECTS OR TIGHTLY LINKED EFFECTS CAN ACCOMPANY TRANSGENICS, BUT THEIR POTENTIAL APPEARS TO BE HIGH, WHEREAS MAPPING IS ONLY GOING TO ALLOW QTL MARKER ASSISTED SELECTION FOR PRESENT GENES. LET US MAKE SURE THAT NO STONE IS LEFT UNTURNED OR UNDERFUNDED. THEREFORE, I THINK THAT MAPPING AND TRANGENIC SHOULD BE ROLLED INTO THE BREEDING BUDGET, AND MAKE SURE BOTH ARE RECOGNIZED BY THE BUDGETERS
JUST MY THOUGHTS.
BOB BUSCH
Robert Busch Research Geneticist
Dr. Robert Busch 411 Borlaug Hall 1991 Buford Circle Univ. of Minnesota St. Paul, MN 55108
PHONE: (612) 625-1975 FAX: (612) 649-5058 OR (612) 625-1268