Scabbies: With Gary's permission, I'm sending this to the whole network. Pardon my single-mindedness, but I urge (dare??) you all to send replies/comments via the scab LISTSERVER. Let's get a rip-roaring discussion going here! To broadcast to the LISTSERVER, use the address: fhbtalk_mg@listserv.msue.msu.edu
If you aren't on the LISTSERVER (and if you did not subscribe you are not on it), you can subscribe by following the instructions from the hyperlink on the left panel of the web site pages (www.scabusa.org).
Rick Ward
-----Original Message----- From: Gary J. Muehlbauer [mailto:Gary.J.Muehlbauer-1@tc.umn.edu] Sent: Wednesday, March 04, 1998 10:38 AM To: Rick ward Subject: Re: 99 budget
Dear Rick:
A couple comments on the initiative. The transformation and germplasm introduction and evaluation portions of this budget look woefully small compared to the breeding effort. I am not convinced that anyone currently has a good source of resistance in their breeding program to develop a resistant line that will withstand a serious infection. Even the best sources of resistance can be wiped out. Therefore, the only approaches that have a chance of working in the end will be transgenics and identifying novel germplasm that carries better resistance. I think these two areas need an increase (at least double for the transgenic effort and I am not sure how much more for germplasm). I would take the money from the breeding effort to support the transgenic and germplasm efforts. I really like the amount that is in the epidemiology and crop management portion. Good crop management practices will be very important when resistant varieties are released. All other portions seem ok.
Gary
This message is an action request for those who attended yesterday's scab initiative meeting, and as information for others.
Below is a text version of my rendering of the broad-stroke budget we discussed yesterday. Note I've reduced the transformation area to $200k (from the $500k I had on the screen at the end of yesterday). The 200k for transformation was extracted from the other 7 original line items more or less proportionately. However, the food safety item took no hit, and the information network took a proportionately big hit (137 down to 100k). Note: I have unilaterally added 50k to the germplasm introduction and evaluation network. I did that after a discussion with Ann McKendry.
A word 6.0/95 version of the table is included as an attachment to this message.
Mike Davis needs this on the hill now. Please email your support or concerns to me as soon as possible. If there is not a problem, I can give Mike the go-ahead today. But please don't let that urgency prevent you
from
voicing your views. Consensus is very important here.
- Food Safety and Post-Harvest Management Research Network $1,000,000
(19%)
- Strengthening and Expansion of Ongoing Plant Breeding Efforts:
Conventional and Molecular Approaches to Variety Development and Germplasm Enhancement $2,400,000 (46 %)
- Regional Advanced Breeding Material Evaluation Nursery System $100,000
(2 %)
Fungicide Application Technology Research Network $350,000 (7 %)
Germplasm Introduction and Evaluation System $250,000 (5 %)
Epidemiology and Crop Management Research $800,000 (15 %)
Project Coordination and Research Information Network $100,000 (2 %)
transformation/transgenics $200,000 (4 %)
Annual Total $5,200,000 (100 %)
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA
Attachment converted: Macintosh HD:99bud1 w6.doc (WDBN/MSWD) (00003E24)
Gary J. Muehlbauer Department of Agronomy and Plant Genetics University of Minnesota St. Paul, MN 55108 phone 612-625-6228 fax 612-625-1268