Kudos, Mike, for coming up with a source of info on this. A very interesting problem which bears scrutiny, particularly if increased vegetative growth of the fungus translates into more inoculum and eventually greater severity of FHB. But of course, corn has been cited as a promoter of FHB growth, so should the same concern be directed at the increasing corn acreages up North? Would the environmentally-concious recommend a return to thoroughly plowing all crop residue down from fencerow to fencerow as a control measure as well? How significant are these effects? At some point we have to accept that there are unintended consequences to most, if not all, of our actions and that if we limit our activities to those that are perfect, we will be able to do nothing
The information that inactive ingredients in the various glyphosate formulations my be responsible for the enhanced growth is extremely interesting. If this is the case, what about other herbicide formulations--perhaps RoundUp is not the only chemical to enhance Fusarium growth? Perhaps herbicides--that is, the inactive ingredients in them-- associated with corn production stimulate Fusarium more than corn itself? I do not know enough about this subject to have answers to my questions, but if there is anything to this it sure bears a closer look.
-- Phil Bregitzer Research Geneticist National Small Grains Germplasm Research Facility USDA-ARS Aberdeen, ID USA
Mike Davis wrote:
The following article that appeared in the The Western Producer
Scientists eye glyphosate-fusarium link web posted: Wednesday July 9, 2003 By Adrian Ewins Saskatoon newsroom
http://www.produce .com/articles/20030703/production/20030703prod02.html
indicates that there is evidence that Roundup (glyphosate) may stimulate the growth of Fusarium (scab). The article focuses on the potential production of Roundup Ready wheat.
What about the use of Roundup as a crop desiccant?
Michael P. Davis, Ph.D. President American Malting Barley Association, Inc. 740 N. Plankinton Ave, Suite 830 Milwaukee, WI 53203 414-272-4640 mpdavis@execpc.com www.AMBAinc.org