Below are suggested guidelines for the winter scab nusery. The comments are complied from replies to my recent email by Greg Shaner, Pat Lipps, Anne McKendry, Rick Ward, Fred Kolb, Scott Haley, and Gene Milus. Anne is also sending this out to Eastern Wheat workers so my apologies if you get it twice. Please continue to comment. We're still in the discussion stage. Although it looks as though my offer to coordinate the nusery is holding steady.
Scott Haley did ask if we would include hard wheats. My feeling is that this should be the winter nusery and Bob Busch can run the spring one. (Rather than separate out by market class).
I see our target group as Eastern Wheat Workers, plus Neb, SD, and KS.
Greg Shaner and Pat LIpps both mentioned that we need to include susceptible checks as well and prefereably both early and late checks because of the association with flowering. I think this is most crucial in spray or corn kernel inoculated nurseries. ***********************************************
Uniform Winter wheat Fusarium head blight nursery
The purpose of this nursery is to evaluate and share breeding lines and potential sources of resistance to Fusarium Head Blight that have a winter habit. Material in the nursery will be available to cooperators for use under the wheat workers code of ethics.
1. The nursery must be restricted in size to 30-40 entries (or some maximum less than 50). This probably won't be a problem initially as people probably don't have that much material yet. 2. Entries must have been identified as having resistance at some level. The nursery isn't intended to screen breeding lines. 3. Entries could intially be released lines although the intent is to screen and make available, good breeding lines. 4. Those growing the nursery must be able to screen it, either in the field or greenhouse or both. 5. Plot size, and inoculation technique will not be standardized, but methods do need to be reported. 6. Four checks will be included, both suceptible and resistant, early and late. The proposed early checks are: Clark or Patterson (S), Ernie (R) OH498 or OH507 (S), Freedom (R) ( if anyone has a favorite late suceptible please suggest it.) 7. The minimum symptoms to be scored are percent head infection and incidence: We need to standardize the rating scale so that it is meaningful to all. We use the Fusarium head blight index widely reported in the literature. (Index = Plot severity= Incidence of infected heads * Head severity.) - From A visual scale to estimate severity of FHB in wheat, Stack and McMullen, NDSU Extension Service.
8. Two other traits need to be evaluated, but probably not by every cooperator: Kernel characteristics, and DON. For Kernel characteristics, I suggest using the scale developed by Bob Busch at MN. For DON, although Rick Ward has indicated that Neogen is willing to cut us a deal, I still have questions regarding sampling technique. My primary concern is that we'll be off the current rating scale for the test kits if we use them on inoculated plots. I suggest that individual cooperators decide how and if they want to evaluate these traits. But that we keep discussing how to coordinate the evaulation and information.
9. Greg Shaner suggested that we have the nursery planted under totally natural inoculation in several locations with the hopes that we'll catch a natural infection at some of them. He indicated that Urbana, Lafayette, and Wooster would have been good sites for such a nursery this year. Then we could have an idea of how lines would perform under natural conditions. This may be a good idea for the initial years when the nursery is small. If inoculated and natural infections result in similar rankings, I'd suggest concentrating on inoculated.
10. I'd prefer to keep seed amounts sent to cooperators uniform for ease in packaging. I'm arbitrarly going to say that each cooperator will recieve 50g of each entry per field location plus the four checks. We'll send 10 g of seed per GH location. This means that each cooperator will have to submit ( 60g * the number of cooperators).
11. Suggested Dates: By July 1, let me know if you want to be a cooperator, what type of nursery (field, GH) whether you have entries to submit, and how many. By August 10, send me enough seed of each of your submissions to supply all cooperators. I'll package and send seed out to all cooperators by Sept. 5. Reports: We'll put together a Web site that can accept data so that the Index values can be reported even before harvest. I'll pull together all the data in a report one time per year, in time for the annual Scab forum in the fall.
Note: Fred Kolb suggested that we need to evaluate cultivars currently in production so that producers can avoid the most suceptible cultivars. This may be the way we can make the fastest short-term progress. I see this as different from the nursery mentioned above. Pat Lipps has put together two tables of cultivar rankings from the Ohio Wheat Performance Trials. The data was collected over two locations in 1995 and 3 in 1996 so I have a high degree of confidence in the cultivar rankings. The table also includes vomitoxin ratings from one location in 1996. We'll have these tables posted on our Web site (http://www.oardc.ohio-state.edu/smgrain) within the week and I can make them available in other formats as well.
I know that other state performance trials rate scab (Anne?) Perhaps we can use this information rather than grow another nursery. What do you think? **************************************
Kim
*************************** Retta, (making chocolate chip cookies) "Here's one cup and then we don't have any more chips." Mom, "You had a whole new bag, where did all the chips go?" Retta, "Well, when Katie and I got home from school, we decided to sample them, and I don't know, we just accidently ate them." Mom, "You mean the chips just accidently jumped out of the bag into your mouth?" Katie Rose, "Yes, that's what happened. It was by accident Mom, really!"
_____________________________________________ Kim Garland Campbell Small Grain Genetics Dept. of Horticulture and Crop Science The Ohio State University/OARDC 1680 Madison Ave. Wooster, OH 44691 (330)263-3886 (phone) (330)263-3887 (fax) _______________________________________________