Thanks for your input Anne. I agree wholeheartedly that the search for additional resistance genes is priority #1. I think that it is safe to say, though, that the breeders would employ significant amounts of the conventional breeding dollars towards indentification/introgression of new sources of resistance. I think our starting point was the obvious need for plant breeding efforts in general, including germplasm evaluation. We then said, hey let's make it very clear that this involves a serious, coordinated effort to bring in world germplasm resources. So we added the germplasm evaluation line. But I see your point.
At 11:22 AM 3/21/97 -0600, you wrote:
Rick: First of all - let me say what a great job you have done putting this together. Many thanks.
I have tried to get more Missouri 'damage' estimates but the only one I have that is firm is $75 million losses in 1991 which was our last state wide epidemic. In each of the years since that, there have been severe regional problems but no state-wide occurrence at epidemic levels.
My main concern in reading through the proposal lies in the relative budgets to plant breeding programs and to germplasm evaluation. Perhaps my confusion stems from not being in Chicago, however, Laura Sweets, who was in Chicago was also not clear on this point and so I raise it with you.
Throughout the proposal we talk of the lack of genes for resistance - yet we are overwhelming in our allocation to plant breeding efforts (for which there are few genes to work with) and have relatively little budgeted to germplasm evaluation i.e. the screening of the national collection. My sense of the best way to approach this effort would be to coordinate (through your spring and winter wheat coordinating centers) a cooperative effort among all of us to screen accessions starting initially by targeting specific parts of the collection based on passport data, ecogeographical data, and the resulting potential for scab resistance to have developed, followed by mass screenings to eliminate obviously susceptible types and then by more detailed evaluations of accessions showing functional levels of resistance.
Now to my question. I appreciate that the detail is probably not worked out, however, is it our intent to fold the collaborative germplasm evaluation effort under the respective plant breeding budgets of participating states, or, is the germplasm evaluation budget intended to cover this effort. I'm not sure that this is clear in the proposal. If the evaluation effort is not covered under the plant breeding budgets, it seems to me that we have very little invested in the critical need to identify new sources of resistance and a lot invested in breeding when we don't have much to work with in our breeding programs.
Sorry this rambles on a bit.
Anne
Anne L. McKendry, PhD Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder 106 Curtis Hall Agronomy Department University of Missouri Columbia, MO 65211 Phone: 573-882-7708 FAX: 573-884-7850 E-Mail: mckendry@psu.missouri.edu
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA