Man is the only animal who fights over imagined treasures. Even the hyena cooperate until they bring down the gazelle. Mark Twain (Samuel Clemens), Diary of a Rich Uncle
I submit that the give and take over who gets what is an exercise in futility. First, we now have a steering committee in place whose function is to direct the research effort. If you have a good idea to sell, sell it to them. Second and more importantly, the 5.2 million dollars is unlikely to be passed by Congress. Let's be realistic. Presently, the federal budget has 1.6 million of which 1.1 goes to ARS. To fully fund land grant research and ARS we would need 6.3 million. However, 5.2 million is the ceiling recognized by our staunchest supporters in Congress. If past performance is a guide, I would be suprised to see more than 3.5 million in the pot, with ARS taking their 1.1 mill and 10% overhead. Therefore, I suggest the research area leaders prepare for the worst by identifying high-impact core research with their area. Double your budget? Use what you get as leverage, don't rob Peter to pay Paul.
Leonard Francl NDSU
P.S. In case you're wondering why you've never heard of "Diary of a Rich Uncle," the quote from one of my favorite authors is a hoax. I'd like to believe he would forgive me.