To: Wheat and barley scab workers From: Rick Ward, co-chair national scab initiative steering committee date: 4/29/98
I'm writing to address some of the questions that I know are being asked about the 'national scab initiative'. I'm just one of the people involved in boot-strapping this thing into existence, and comments I make here or elsewhere simply represent my best shot at understanding what's going on.
During FY 98 (now), scientists in 12 states are sharing $444,000 of federal funds awarded through ARS to work on scab in all classes of wheat and barley. Those funds arose from lobbying efforts by the 12 states last summer and fall. In November, an ad-hoc working committee met at the national scab forum and endorsed ARS's suggestion that we open the effort to all states. That is how we started calling the effort the 'national' scab initiative.
The initiative has been successful to date because it is unique marriage of the varied industry sectors, disciplines, institutions, and regions. Unique in that a system of communication and collaboration that is nationally inclusive of all stakeholders from seed to flour (or beer, or other products) has not existed in any major crop, including wheat and barley. Our efforts with the 12 states and ARS gave us enough of a critical mass to show how we can work together in synergistic ways, but the invisible boundaries defining our lack of a national network are still in place outside the 12-states (and in reality inside that region too).
So we have been temporarily in the awkward position of selling the idea of a national system of scab research while there is in fact no such system! One of the costs of not being nationally organized is that individual researchers often are unaware of activity or interests of other scab scientists (or potential scab scientists). The initiative is not immune to this problem. This has resulted in lots of people wondering if they can participate or not. These growing pains are to be expected. If we already had a smoothly operating national scab research system in place we would not need to be creating this one.
The fundamental aim of the initiative is to maximally reduce the risk of scab to consumers, growers, and processors as quickly as possible. Who should participate in that effort: its simple- whoever can contribute. How can you contribute? I see two ways- 1) help identify the best organizational structures for maximizing the return on research dollars, and 2) finding and deploying solutions through science and technology.
It is a mistake for us to leave one scientist out of the loop when he/she could have made a contribution. If you feel left out, let us know. By 'us', I mean the steering committee. See the web site at www.scabusa.org for more details (I've delinquent in updating the site- I'm working on it!).
Please send this and any other communication on the initiative on to others you think are being left out. If you can help find better ways of doing things, make your ideas known.
Finally- the big push for FY99 funding will occur over the next 4-8 weeks. In the next two weeks we need to iron out the broad outline of a plan and budget for achieving our goals. Speaking with one mutually supportive voice can allow us to inject up to $5M into the scab research system of the US. Speaking with many fractured voices will harm our collective efforts. The one voice solution can only occur if all stakeholders feel they are included and being listened to. Please know that we know that and we are listening.
regards,
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA