Dear Colleague,
I am writing to inform you of a new program created by the Chemical and Biological Control committee of the US Wheat & Barley Scab Initiative to provide standardized evaluations of biological control agents (SEB). Guidelines for those who may wish to participate by providing a test site can be found below. Those of you who have participated in the USWBSI Uniform Fungicide and Biological Control Trials will be familiar with most of the guidelines, but you will find additional ones that address special handling and quality control procedures for biologicals. As the program's tentative coordinator, I invite you to submit a preproposal to the USWBSI relating to this program and look forward to working with you.
Sincerely yours,
Gary Yuen
*****************************************************************************
Gary Y. Yuen Associate Professor University of Nebraska - Lincoln Department of Plant Pathology 406 Plant Science Hall Lincoln, NE 68583-0722 Office: (402) 472-3125; Lab: (402) 472-0379; FAX: (402) 472-2853 email: gyuen@unl.edu *****************************************************************************
Guidelines For Testers Participating In Standardized Evaluation Of Biologicals (SEB)
In these guidelines "originating laboratory" is the one that isolated the biological agent and wants to have it tested, while "participating tester" or "tester" is the laboratory that is conducting field test for efficacy. Recognizing that all biological treatments in these evaluations are experimental and none are commercially mass-produced, testing of biologicals will involve most of the standard procedures used in testing fungicides, but also entail additional requirements as to propagation, handling and quality control. Therefore, these guidelines are divided into standard and "special biological" categories.
Standard guidelines
Plan for 6 treatments (4 biocontrol treatments, 1 non-treated check, and Folicur).
Have at least 4 replications.
Plot size should be 5 ft X 10 ft minimum.
Enhance the probability of getting scab by inoculating with the pathogen and/or misting. If pathogen inoculation is through spraying of conidia, allow a period of at least 1 day between biocontrol treatments and pathogen inoculation.
One application per treatment - in most cases, the timing of application is early flowering, Feekes 10.51 (15-25% of main stems in anthesis). Some biologicals might function by inducing host resistance and thus may require applications prior to anthesis (see "Early applications" below).
Apply all treatments in 20 gal/acre at approximately 40 psi.
Application equipment - CO2 sprayer that has a boom equipped with double swivel adaptors (part # QJ8600-2-1/4 inch-NY) to allow 2 nozzles (XR TEEJET 8001VS flat fan) to be connected at each opening on the boom. Adjust the adaptor so that one nozzle points forward at 30o from horizontal and the other nozzle points backward at 30o from horizontal. A typical boom for spraying 5-ft-wide plots would have 3 adaptors and 6 nozzles. The forward and backward nozzle orientation is important to get good coverage of the heads. Adaptors and nozzles can be purchased from R&D Sprayers ( http://www.co2sprayers.com/).
Efficacy data - field severity (% spikelets infected per head) and incidence (% heads infected per plot) must be determined from at least 40 heads per plot around 3 weeks after anthesis. Plots should be harvested for determination of seed yield and incidence of tombstone kernals. Samples from each plot should be sent to appropriate laboratories for analysis of DON content.
Special biological guidelines
Bacterial and fungal culturing capability- While it is preferable that each biological control agent be propagated by the originating laboratory and sent to participating testers ready for application, it may necessary for a testing laboratory to produce inoculants for local testing. Therefore, participating testers should have the capacity to culture bacteria or fungi using standard agar or broth media. Starter cultures, explicit culturing instructions, and if needed, uncommon or costly culture reagents, will be provided by the originating laboratory.
Preapplication handling and quality control - Participating testers must have the capacity to store microbial inoculants and transport them to field experiment sites at room temperature or on ice. In addition, the tester must collect a small sample of each inoculant just prior to application and assay populations in the sample.
Application conditions - The tester should arrange for applications to be made to avoid highest ultraviolet, temperature, wind velocity, i.e. early evening or under cloudy skies.
Post application sampling and assay for biocontrol agent populations - Population numbers of applied biocontrol agents on wheat heads provide important information in understanding why a treatment may or may not have been effective in a given test site. Participating testers should be prepared to collect wheat head samples (multiple heads from a plot are to be pooled into a sample) 1 and 7 days after treatment and either assay the samples according to protocols provided by the originating laboratory or arrange for overnight shipment of samples to the originating laboratory.
Early application of biological treatments - Biocontrol agents that function by induced resistance need to be applied ahead of pathogen inoculation (usually 5 to 7 days). Early application is particularly justified if the agent also can control other pathogens that infect prior to heading. Therefore, the participating tester should accommodate earlier application of certain treatments if the originating laboratory has evidence that earlier application is warranted.
Efficacy and population data - Participant must transmit efficacy results and data on pre- and post-application populations, on an individual plot basis, to the originating laboratories and to the SEB coordinator.
Environment data - Participating tester should obtain environmental data (e.g., air temperature, relative humidity, light conditions, rainfall, wind speed) from weather stations closest to experiment sites. The data should be collected during the period from first application of treatments to reading of field disease results.