Date: Fri, 14 Mar 1997 18:09:16 -0500 (EST) X-Sender: kcampbel@pop.service.ohio-state.edu To: Rick ward wardri@pilot.msu.edu From: kcampbel@pop.service.ohio-state.edu (Kim Campbell) Subject: Re: Proposal
Rick THis is for the list but I'm not sure if this is the right address. Kim
Hi all. I thought I'd weigh in with a few comments as well since Rick mentioned my name. First I have a comment or two on Greg and Rick's discussion, then a comment on the project focus areas.
I agree that it would be helpful to phenotype RIL popualtions at several locations and I agree that we would be well served choosing perhaps a winter and a spring population that we can all share. But I also agree with Rick that the use of marker technology is much broader than 'mapping genes in Sumai3 for scab resistance'. And if we make the mistake of limiting ourselves to the above goal, we're much too short sighted.
Marker technology has languished in wheat for two reasons: 1. difficulties with the size of the genome and lack of polymorphism and 2. lack of funding. ITMI regularly get's its funding requests halved or redirected etc. If we had half the resources of the Arabidopsis folks . . . And we don't have any seed companies spending money on us.
Here is a reason for us to collaborate and work hard to advance our use of a technology that is becoming SOP in maize and tomato. Are we talking about building infrastructure and funding research that will play a large role in improving the value of our crop? YES. Is it limited to scab, NO. But scab is enough of a threat to eliminate the crop in the corn belt states (perhaps there's some self preservation instinct operating here as well. I've just closed down an oat program and do not want to do the same for wheat).
The germplasm introduction and breeding work we're talking about is similar in its broad benefit to the crop as a whole. Scab gives us the rationale. I don't see the difference, why should every state participate in traditional breeding but not in the marker phase - if you truly believe that marker's are a necessarry component of breeding programs in the 21st century. As much so as tractors, combines and greenhouses.
And if you don't believe that markers are a necessarry component of breeding programs, then why should we fund markers at all?
OK, my second point - Out of a budget of 4.2 million, we currently have 2.25 million for breeding related activities. Perhaps this isn't out of line since everyone in the room thought that a genetic solution was the most feasible. And the development time for a genetic solution is probably shorter than for a chemical solution. We're in the process of eliminating super susceptibles now. Within the next five years I think the ESRWW cultivar base ought to be up to moderately resistant. BUT I'm concerned that we had four focus areas: Plant breeding, Crop management strategies, Epidemiology, and ensuring food safety through processing. Are our proposed funding areas and amounts reflecting these four areas in proper emphasis? Speak up plant pathologists (!).
Finally, are there political reasons why we might want to emphasize anything more than we've done. For example, I think placing this much emphasis on breeding is a political statement that we value breeding as an economic and environmentally safe option. (And, by extension, that we value the work of plant breeders.). Do we need to emphasize the work of plant pathology in a similar fashion? Food safety ? Or have we done so.
Sorry to muddy waters . Have a good weekend. Kim
Retta (age9): 'Mom, are we rich or poor?' Mom: 'We're not as rich as some but we have more than many.' Katie Rose (age 5): 'That's 'cause we have lots of money in the basement!' Mom: 'We do?' Katie Rose: 'Yep, We get it from Daddy's pants pockets!' _____________________________________________ Kim Garland Campbell Small Grain Genetics Dept. of Horticulture and Crop Science The Ohio State University/OARDC 1680 Madison Ave. Wooster, OH 44691 (330)263-3886 (phone) (330)263-3887 (fax) _______________________________________________
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA