From: Jackie Rudd, Anne McKendry, Herb Ohm, Rich Horsely, and R. Ward To: US Wheat and Barley Scab workers
We are acting as an ad hoc committee to generate the FY99 work plan and budget for the "Strengthening and Expansion of Ongoing Plant Breeding Efforts" component of the national scab initiative. The goal of this area is to maximize levels of scab resistance of US wheat and barley varieties (all classes/species) in the shortest time possible. We believe that the most important targets of this area's funds should be conventional field and greenhouse breeding activities. We recognize that molecular markers can also fit under this goal. However, as a matter of policy we believe that funding for conventional activities should be secured in full before major molecular marker projects are funded. In a separate message we will request proposals for major molecular marker projects such as the development of SSR's or gene tagging studies. This policy represents a compromise that we think reflects an appropriate balance between the short term and long term goals.
Note that funds for germplasm introduction, regional uniform testing systems, and transgenic systems are handled under separate sections of the scab initiative plan.
We therefore request that each of the at-risk breeding public programs ('at-risk' means programs targeting variety development for areas that have been damaged by scab in recent years) submit a pre-proposal for funding to achieve the goal outlined above. Examples from North Dakota and Purdue are found at the end of this message. You should provide enough detail for us to understand the intent of the activity and how it fulfills the goals, but please be as concise as possible. We ask that you submit these pre-proposals by April 24, 1998.
It is critical that the proposals reflect a consensus of the key scientists contributing to the breeding programs. In particular, proposals need to demonstrate how both plant breeders and plant pathologists will work together. We suggest that each program's proposal include both plant breeders and pathologists as co-PI's.
Eventually, we will have to reconcile the magnitude of our collective needs with the magnitude of the funds actually available. But at this point, we are not imposing any limits on the funds that a program can request. Instead, we are relying on your good sense to avoid inflated budget requests.
These pre-proposals will help us craft a system-wide proposal for this area. We will probably be asking for revisions after seeing the first submissions.
An example of a proposal from Purdue follows: [a note from H. Ohm to R. Ward] Rick:
Below is the proposed budget for our breeding program at Purdue to carry out soft wheat improvement to incorporate effective resistance to Fusarium graminearum. Note that most of the funding resources are for additional technician, graduate student and student labor support and funds for research supplies and expenses. We simply need additional personnel support to carry out a plant breeding program that focuses on scab resistance to complement our current research for the many other agronomic, end use qualities, and resistance to other important diseases, viruses and Hessian fly. The budget also includes a one-time funding request for equipment items that we need for this research, but do not have other funds to purchase the two items.
This budget is communicated to you for overall scab initiative budgeting purposes. We can develop our proposal further as needed to provide a Statement of the importance of scab in Indiana, Justification of the proposed research, the Objectives are stated below, a Plan of research, and Research Timetable.
Scab Breeding. Objective: To develop improved soft winter wheat cultivars and useful germplasm lines that have resistance to Fusarium graminearum.
I. Technical Position devoted to scab breeding (germplasm screening, evaluation, enhancement) $ 40,000. 10,000. from Coop. Nursery funds 10,000. from Germplasm Eval. funds 20,000. from Plant Breeding funds
Two 1/2-time Graduate Assistantship positions (one to do classical genetics on several T. aestivum sources of scab resistance that we are working with, development and characterization of genetic populations and DNA marker development. The second position to transfer scab resistance from certain wheat relatives into wheat). Provide assistance in scab breeding. (2 @ $ 20,000) $ 40,000.
Part time labor 15,000.
Supplies and Expenses 15,000.
II. DNA markers, resistance gene analog cloning. Our objectives are to develop markers that are closely linked to specific resistance genes and to clone a scab resistance gene. We have developed wheat lines that have single scab resistance genes. We are generating at least 1000 resistance gene analogs (clones) for Ning7840. These clones need to be sequenced and analyzed. Gel blot analysis using Ning7840 and Clark will be performed to determine the linkage between the resistance gene analogs and resistance for scab.
Post doctoral position 40,000. from DNA marker/mapping fund
Supplies and Expenses 20,000. "
Gel documentation system (one-time expenditure) 11,000. "
END
Best regards,
Herb
____________________________________________________________________________ _______ The North Dakota example follows: {note from R. Horsley to B. Busch]
Bob:
The wheat and barley breeders at NDSU developed the following list as priorities for receiving breeding funds for FHB resistance over the next five years. Funding is for each year except where noted. I am going to gone for the next two weeks harvesting my winter nursery in Yuma. If you have any questions, you can contact Elias or Richard Frohberg. See you in Yuma.
Overall, we agree with the comments made last week that the first FHB resistant wheat and barley varieties will be developed using conventional methods. We feel it is important to have and maintain strong breeding programs that can use conventional and molecular marker approaches to develop new cultivars. Moreover, funding of biotechnology approaches should not come at the expense of conventional approaches. We need to identify bottlenecks in our current programs that slow down the release of FHB resistant varieties.
One bottleneck we forsee is in evaluating quality (baking, pasta, milling, malting, and brewing). As we identify resistant progenies, we will screen greater more material for quality to find the lines that have FHB resistance and acceptable quality. In the two barley breeding programs at NDSU, we saw a 50% increase in the number of lines we sent to Dr. Paul Schwarz's lab for early generation screening. We saw corresponding increases in the size of our winter nurseries in Arizona. Richard Frohberg increased about 40 lines in New Zealand this winter that have FHB resistance. This number of lines would not have been increased in the past. However, without quality and yield data from multiple years and locations, we need to test more lines with the hope that at least one of them will have the agronomic, disease reistance, and quality traits that growers need.
In general, the five breeding programs at NDSU (hard red spring wheat, white and specialty wheats, durum wheat, 6-rowed barley and 2-rowed barley) identified the following areas where funding is needed: winter nurseries, DON testing, FHB testing, other disease testing, and quality evaluation. Each of the five programs felt they needed an additional $7,500 for winter nurseries and $25,000 general operating expences. A more specific breakdown for each crop is outlined below. I am
Durum Wheat Winter nursery $ 7,500 NIR ?? (one year only) DON testing $7,500 Research specialist (durum breeding) $33,000 Research chemist (cereal science) $33,000 Operating (including hourly labor durum breeding) $25,000 Molecular marker screening $5,000
Hard red spring wheat Winter nursery $ 10,000 DON testing $22,500 Hourly labor (cereal science) $15,000 Hourly labor (plant pathology) $10,000 Operating (including hourly labor wheat breeding) $25,000 Molecular marker screening $5,000
White and specialty wheat Winter nursery $ 7,500 DON testing $7,500 Research specialist (wheat breeding) $33,000 Hourly labor (cereal science) $5,000 Hourly labor (plant pathology) $5,000 Operating (including hourly labor wheat breeding) $25,000 Molecular marker screening $5,000
Two-rowed barley Winter nursery $ 7,500 DON testing $4,800 Research specialist (2-rowed barley breeding) $33,000 Operating (including hourly labor) $25,000 China FHB screening nurseries $2,500 Molecular marker screening $5,000
Six-rowed barley Winter nursery $ 7,500 DON testing $6,400 China FHB screening nurseries $5,000 Operating (including hourly labor) $25,000 Molecular marker screening $5,000
Barley Quality Lab - NDSU Joe White malting unit (one year only) $80,000 Automated mashers (one year only) $45,000 Research chemist $33,000 Operating $5,000
Please send proposals to:
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA