Thanks for your reply, Greg. It looks like 10:00 is the time that will allow all of us to assemble on the 13th. We can initiate informal discussions earlier. I know that the Michigan and Ohio folk arrive obscenely early, before 7:00 am.
At 09:19 AM 3/8/97 -0500, you wrote:
Reply to: RE>meeting agendaRick, Fungicides (assuming some can be found that are effective, e.g. Bravo?) and resistant cultivars will probably be the quickest "fix" for scab, so I would recommend we put those items at the beginning of the agenda, and discuss the other items later in the day, as time permits. Herb already sent a memo to you about his ideas for shuttle breeding. This sounds feasible for much of the winter wheat region. Do you think this would work for the maturity class of cultivars grown in Michigan? If so, we should discuss implementing this program, with the idea of getting at least one or two cultivars from each participating AES developed and released as quickly as possible. We can also discuss how to use this shuttle approach to infuse scab resistance into as much of our germplasm as quickly as possible. After all, it won't help to have a scab resistant cultivar if it does not have good yield and soft wheat quality, along with other desirable agronomic traits, and resistance to other diseases of importance. Related to this, we need to hammer out details of a uniform scab nursery to be grown probably in at least one location in each state. Should this nursery include only lines near release, or should it include more preliminary germplasm? Should all of the nursery sites be inoculated and provided with artificial moisture, or should we rely on natural epidemics at some of the sites? If we inoculate and provide moisture, should we follow some stanard protocol at every site, and what should that protocol be? The experiments on sources of inoculum, distance of spore dispersal, timing of dispersal, etc. are important for understanding why the disease has become more important, and we should discuss a regional effort on this. We might want two centers of coordination for this research -- one in the spring wheat area, where wheat and barley are a major component of the cropping system, and another in the soft winter wheat region, where corn and soybeans are much more abundant. As to nomenclature, I always prefer shorter names over longer ones, so I like scab. When J. C. Arthur described this disease in 1891 he said that scab was what the farmers called this malady. I don't know why they referred to this head blight disease as scab, because the symptoms don't seem to have anything to do with a scab (roughened scab-like spots on leaves, fruit, tubers, etc.). Anyway, that is a name of long standing, and it is the preferred name listed in the APS "Common Names of Plant Diseases" so I would prefer it over Fusarium head blight. Incidentally, the alternative name in the APS book is "head blight" not "Fusarium head blight." As for the pathogen name, either Gibberella zeae or Fusarium graminearum is okay. The "true" name for the fungus is Gibberella zeae (the teleomorph), but anamorph names (e.g. Fusarium graminearum) are acceptable, especially when this is the state involved in a plant disease. However, we think that ascospores are the primary inoculum for scab, so it seems appropriate to refer to the fungus as G. zeae. It also makes it a little easier to talk to farmers, millers, and others because we can also refer to Gibberella ear and stalk rot of corn. In any event, I don't think we should waste too much time in Chicago on terminology. It does not make any difference to me whether the group wants to call itself the North Central Fusasrium Head Blight Consortium or the North Central Scab Consortium. This latter name might conjur images of anti-unionism. Have you set a start time for the meeting yet? Regards, Greg
Rick Ward
Associate Professor/Wheat Breeder Michigan State University wardri@pilot.msu.edu (517)-355-2231(land) (517)-285-9725 (cell) (517)-353-3955 (fax) address: MSU/Dept of CSS 382 PSSB East Lansing MI 48824 USA