Everyone,
It seems to me that an important consideration in the distribution of funds
is "What are we expecting to do using markers?" If the answer is that we
intend to incorporate the use of markers into our breeding programs then it
seems to me that each state needs to get some of the funds. I believe Greg
is raising the question "What will be the most efficient initially?" This a
valid question, but if we concentrate most of the funds for marker research
at two locations the other states may not have as much capacity to do
research in that area and therefore may not employ markers as quickly as if
the capacity was present. Thus, while concentrating the funding may help
initially, I believe it may slow overall progress in the longer term. In my
opinion, in the proposal, we should spell out the total amount of funding
for markers, but not necessarily the breakdown by state. If only several
sites are funded for marker work, then those locations MUST agree to work
with materials from other programs. One disadvantage to centralizing may be
that some breeders might not limit the material they're sending to another
location as much as if they were doing it themselves. (It's easy for me to
send a few thousand samples to Purdue, for example, if I know they're going
to do the markers. I might be a bit more selective and cut that down more
if I know I'm going to have to do them myself!)
Only two locations may be more efficient, but with more locations slightly
different approaches and ideas will be tried and this may increase the
chances of success also.
Fred
At 08:34 AM 3/17/97 -0500, you wrote:
> Reply to: RE>Kim Campbell comments
>
>>From the response of Rick and Kim to my comments about markers, my remarks may
>have been misconstrued. I was not suggesting that we only map the Sumai
>3/Ning 7840 resistance. However, that seems to be what almost everybody is
>working with, and the only resistance that has been genetically characterized
>so far. As other sources of resitance are discovered AND characterized
>genetically and phenotypically, they should also be mapped. I agree with Rick
>that there seem to be several other sources of resistance, both "exotic" amd
>within adapted cultivars, but until these are carefully characterized, I think
>it is premature to look for markers.
>The main point of my comments was is it necessary for every state to do the
>screening for markers for the same source of resistance? My idea was that one
>or two labs should concentrate on Rick's objective no. 1 for a given source of
>resistance. Once putative markers are found, these should be made available
>to all states to pursue objectives 2 and 3. Since I don't do marker work
>myself, I don't know what the relative costs of objectives 1, 2, and 3 are,
>but I have the impression that No. 1 (finding the markers) can be very
>expensive because it is such a "needle in the haystack" proposition. Maybe
>some of the newer marker technologies are more efficient.
>Anyway, my original question still stands. Will it look bad to send in a
>proposal that shows the marker budget being equally divided among all states?
>Will the proposal be stronger if it shows an overall budget for marker work,
>and specifies that this money will be used for the three objectives Rick
>mentions, and that money will will allocated to states according to the degree
>of their participation in these three objectives? If it turns out that there
>are enough different sources of resistance that are genetically charactized
>for every state to share in all three objectives, and therefore each state
>gets about the same amount of marker money, then that's fine.
>With regard to Kim's second point about the allocation of money over the
>general objectives, I don't see plant pathology and plant breeding as entirely
>separate activities with respect to scab. Plant breeders and plant
>pathologists will need to work closely together to develop reliable screening
>techniques and evaluate germplasm. I am not sure that breeding will be a
>quicker fix than fungicides. If effective fungicides are found, there are
>mechansisms for getting special use permits and these could be in place
>probably sooner than resistant cultivars would be generally available. This
>partly depends on whether an effective fungicide is already registered for use
>in the US. The epidemiology work is important, but by itself will not provide
>a radical solution to the scab problem. We already have a good idea about the
>reasons why scab has become a much greater problem in recent years.
>Additional studies on epidemiology will fill in some gaps in our knowledge and
>refine our understanding of the conditions favorable for disease. These
>studies will certainly help create reliable resistance or fungicide screening
>tests. So, I think the overall allocation of money among the various control
>strategies is logical and should provide the greatest chance for putting scab
>control solutions in farmers' hands in the shortest possible time.
>
>Regards,
>Greg
>
>
>
e-mail: f-kolb(a)uiuc.edu
Frederic L. Kolb ph. (217) 244-6148
Dep. of Crop Sciences FAX (217) 333-9817
University of Illinois
1102 S. Goodwin Ave., Urbana, IL 61801